| Date | Game | Result | Score | Notes |
|---|
| 12/20/2025 | Kentucky vs. (#22) St. Johns | W | 78 - 66 | CBS Sports Classic (at Atlanta, GA) |
| 12/1/2011 | St. Johns at (#1) Kentucky | W | 81 - 59 | SEC/Big East Invitational |
| 11/9/2000 | (#12) Kentucky vs. St. Johns | L | 61 - 62 | Coaches vs. Cancer IKON Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 12/30/1992 | (#3) Kentucky vs. St. Johns | W | 86 - 77 | ECAC Holiday Festival (at New York, NY) |
| 3/22/1985 | Kentucky vs. (#3) St. Johns | L | 70 - 86 | NCAA West Regional Semifinals (at Denver, CO) |
| 12/17/1977 | St. Johns at (#1) Kentucky | W | 102 - 72 | UKIT Championship |
| 3/22/1952 | (#1) Kentucky vs. (#10) St. Johns | L | 57 - 64 | NCAA East Regional Finals (at Raleigh, NC) |
| 12/17/1951 | (#2) St. Johns at (#1) Kentucky | W | 81 - 40 | - |
| 3/22/1951 | (#1) Kentucky vs. (#9) St. Johns | W | 59 - 43 | NCAA East Regional Semifinals (at New York, NY) |
| 12/23/1950 | (#1) Kentucky at (#13) St. Johns | W | 43 - 37 | (at New York, NY) |
| 12/15/1949 | Kentucky at St. Johns | L | 58 - 69 | (at New York, NY) |
| 12/18/1948 | Kentucky at St. Johns | W | 57 - 30 | (at New York, NY) |
| 12/23/1947 | Kentucky at St. Johns | W | 52 - 40 | (at New York, NY) |
| 12/21/1946 | Kentucky at St. Johns | W | 70 - 50 | (at New York, NY) |
| 12/29/1945 | Kentucky at St. Johns | W | 73 - 59 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/22/1944 | Kentucky vs. St. Johns | L | 45 - 48 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 12/30/1943 | Kentucky at St. Johns | W | 44 - 38 | (at New York, NY) |
